Time Out New York: "Its not beauty that provides a reason for living, but the constant search for it."
Date: Aug 24 2008
The main characters in Muriel Barbery’ novel have a tendency to ponder lofty issues: “What is the nature of human consciousness? What do we know of the world?” muses 54-year-old Madame Michel. And then they address them. At length. (“Let’s start with the first question…”) Barbey likes aphorisms, too: “Grammar is a way to attain beauty,” states Paloma Josse, 12. Yet the book, a huge best-seller in Barbery’s native France, almost never comes across like a lecture in disguise (unlike Jostein Gaarder’s philosophically minded Sophie’s World, for instance), because the connective tissue between the various pearls of wisdom feels genuinely novelistic.
Madame Michel is the cocierge in the posh Parisian building where Paloma lives. The older woman, a “proletarian autodidact,” takes great pains to disguise her sharp intellect and refined tastes from the people she serves, but Paloma, a misanthropic prodigy planning to kill herself when she turns 13, is too mired in self-absorption to realize a kindred soul actually lives a few floors below her. For most of the book, they croos each other but don’t see each other; it takes the arrival of a new tenant, Kakuro Ozu, to open everybody’s eyes, minds and hearts (the author isn’t above a certain sentimentality).
The aforementioned two queries, tossed off in an early chapter about phenomenology (yeah, it’s that kind of novel), actually lead up to one of Barbery’s essential concerns: What is our purpose in life? It takes many digressions to reach a conclusion, but by the end of the book you realize that the process is part of the point: It’s not beauty that provides a reason for living, but the constant search for it.